What examiners look for
Nine questions about the minerals in a trust account, and how we answer each one.
The questions below come from the federal rule, the examiners' guidance, and state law. Texas and Oklahoma are examples. We follow the rules that apply to each account, in every state where it holds minerals. Each answer states what we provide. The decisions on what happens next stay with the bank.
01
Is each mineral interest still right for the account?
The yearly review asks whether each asset is "appropriate, individually and collectively, for the account" (12 CFR 9.6(c)). We work with the trust officer to run scenarios on what each interest is worth under the bank's own valuation standard, and show what it should pay and how it compares with the account's other choices. The decision on each interest is theirs.
02
What should we check when minerals first come into an account?
The federal rule calls for "a prompt review of all assets of the account" when a bank accepts a fiduciary account with investment discretion (12 CFR 9.6(b)). Oklahoma's statute, for example (60 O.S. §175.64), says a trustee shall review the trust assets "within a reasonable time after accepting a trusteeship or receiving trust assets." For minerals, that first review sets the record every later review depends on. We check title and each decimal against the county record, list every interest with its payor and lease status, find any payments already held in suspense, and note which interests are working interests that carry costs as well as income.
03
What is the interest worth?
Listing each mineral interest at a nominal $1, according to the OCC handbook, is "not likely to reflect the significance of the assets being managed." At Lodemark, our engineers value each interest from its actual production. Larger producing interests get a full engineering valuation; small interests can be valued from their recent production history, as the guidance allows. We run the valuation scenarios the bank's standard calls for, such as its own written policy or SEC pricing, so the trust officer can see what the interest is worth across a range of prices.
04
How does it compare with other investments?
Examiners expect the bank to "compare the unique asset's performance with other similar assets and other potential investments" (OCC handbook). We set each interest's income and value beside similar interests in the same area and beside the account's other options, as information for the trust officer's review.
05
Is the income what it should be?
The OCC handbook asks a bank to "anticipate the timing and estimated amount of income payments," and says a payment that's missing or unusual "should prompt further inquiry." Our monthly monitoring tracks the items state examiners check, such as delay rentals, lease expirations, income received, and changes in regular payments (Texas's list, for example). We forecast what each interest should pay, check every statement against it, and when a payment doesn't come, we find out why and tell you. When an operator holds payments in suspense, we find the cause and work with the operator to have the payments released. On one estate, our work recovered more than $3.5 million in missed value.
06
Are the ownership records right?
Before a trust department relies on a division order, the OCC handbook says it "should first ensure that the ownership percentages and production shares are accurate." Texas examiners, for example, look for "evidence of title, including a filed conveyance to the trustee in the county in which the interest is located" (T06, Appendix D, item 4a). Our land team checks title and the ownership decimal against the county record. Where a filing is needed, such as an affidavit of ownership or a conveyance to the trustee, we arrange it through the licensed attorneys we work with in each state we actively cover.
07
Are the leases being honored, and which ones are about to expire?
Texas examiners, for example, look for a "determination of status" for each interest (leased or unleased, producing or not), and check whether the department follows up on "delayed rental payments" and the "expiration of leases" (T06, Appendix D, items 4g, 6a, and 6b). We review each lease for what it lets the operator do and whether its terms are being met, and we track every expiration date. When a new lease is on the table, we bring the terms of recent leases on comparable interests nearby, which the OCC handbook says a fiduciary "should try to obtain." Where the trust owns the surface, we also handle surface damage agreements.
08
What about working interests?
Working interests carry costs as well as income. Before a bank approves an AFE, the OCC handbook says it "should be knowledgeable about the industry, the operations of the particular interest, and the operator." Our engineering team reviews every AFE before you decide whether to participate. Review of the insurance clauses in working-interest leases is available, and when a property needs an inspection, the inspection is arranged through outside providers.
09
How are mineral receipts split between principal and income?
Oklahoma's statute, for example (60 O.S. §175.411), says a royalty receipt "must be allocated fifteen percent (15%) to principal and eighty-five percent (85%) to income," and gives bonuses and delay rentals their own rule. We prepare the allocation figures from the trust's terms and the governing state's law for the trust officer to review and book. Tax support on depletion, DD&A, and tax basis is available, as is accounting support up to full-service accounting.